A Little Late Kate Beckinsale?

A Little Late Kate?:

Worn Out

By ANTOINETTE BUENO

Last night Kate Beckinsale made waves in a hot-pink satin Alexander McQueen dress she wore to the Vanity Fair and Chrysler Celebration of the Eva Longoria Foundation at Eva's restaurant Beso in Hollywood -- a dress which has been worn before by both Lucy Liu and Amber Heard over four years ago.

But is her vintage choice justified because she looks the best in this sassy cap-sleeve number? That one is pretty debatable! Take a look at all three ladies (starting with Lucy who wore it first) and you decide -- who wore it best?